Defence Attorneys object to Prosecution use of statements from accused in its submissions in MV Barima murder case

Defence Attorneys object to Prosecution use of statements from accused in its submissions in MV Barima murder case

Police Prosecutor Mandel Moore has tendered over 200 exhibits as the paper committal proceedings in the MV Barima Murder Case commenced on Monday in the Suddie Magistrates’ Court before Magistrate Ravindra Mohabir. The Prosecution’s submission faced fierce objections from the Defence when the Prosecutor attempted to tender the original statements of the three accused.

The three accused – 40-year-old Kevin Price, the boat captain; 33-year-old goods superintendent Delon Granderson and 42-year-old Rondell Dwayne Roberts, the chief mate are facing 72 counts of murder in relation to MV Barima ferry tragedy.

On Monday, the Prosecution tendered the exhibits, which were largely statements to support its case.

The Defence challenged the admissibility of the statements from the three accused under the Criminal Law Procedure (Paper Committals) Act.  

It was Glenn Hanoman, who is the attorney for the Good Superintendent Rondell Roberts, who first objected to Price’s statement being tendered as he questioned whether the accused statements, without more would be admissible.

“I am not sure if the prosecution is attempting to use what is contained in that statement against Rondell Roberts. Because when it comes to the statement of Rondell Roberts, we will be objecting to the admissibility of that statement” Hanoman told the Court.

Dexter Todd – the Attorney for Price and Granderson – also objected to the attempt by the Prosecution to tender the ordinary statements of the accused persons. Todd said he thought the Court would have embarked on a Case Management Conference (CMC) for the parties to be informed of the number of statements to be tendered, and their origins.

“I was not of the opinion that the prosecution would attempt to tender everything that was disclosed because he cannot tender the statements of the accused, the ordinary statements of the accused,” Todd told the Court.

Interjecting, Prosecutor Moore informed the Court that the Prosecution intends to tender everything that was disclosed, including the statements from the three accused.  

“This is a paper committal; this is not the trial. And even though the ordinary statement of one accused cannot be used against himself or another co-accused right now, it is unclear or not certain as to what the position might be when these men are committed to stand trial or if or when they are indicted. Several things could occur which may include them being indicted separately, which can include probably just one or two of them committed,” the Prosecutor reasoned.

He said based on the outcome, they could very well be asked to serve as witnesses in the case at the level of the High Court.

As he maintained that the statements of the three accused are admissible, the Prosecutor relied heavily on the Section 8 of the Criminal Law Procedure (Paper Committals) Act. He submitted that written statements made by any person could be admitted once the requirements outlined in the law are met.

But Todd told the Court that he has never heard such “magical explanation” in Criminal Law, as he pushed back against the attempt by Moore to have the statements of the accused tendered.

Todd submitted that the Court cannot allow the Prosecution to present a case for future dissection.

“The Court has to determine what is before it. What is before it, is a joined charged of murder. And so, the Court has to apply the rules in relation to that. If the Prosecution intends to separate the charges, then the Prosecution can so do. But the Prosecution can’t present a case in relation to three people and ask that the ordinary statement of one of the accused forms part of the Prosecution’s case. What the court is tendering at this stage is the Prosecution’s case,” Todd maintained.

He said the Prosecution’s case cannot be statements from Price or any of the other accused because they are not likely to be called as witnesses for the Prosecution.

Everton Singh-Lammy, who is also representing Roberts, also registered his objections. He told the Court that it is extremely bold of the Prosecution to say that those statements in contention are admissible.

“There is a test that needs to be undertaken by the Court before they reach to the state of admissibility. So, just on the face of that statement it is not admissible. And now, the Prosecutor is trying to tender statements of people who really he has no control of,” Singh-Lammy submitted.

Hanoman added that the Prosecutor may have fallen into the trap that the Paper Committals Act allows him to tender anything “willy-nilly” but that’s not the case. In support of their arguments, Hanoman pointed the Court to Section 25 of the Criminal Law Procedure (Paper Committals Act), which outlines the general rules of evidence.

On hearing the preliminary arguments, Magistrate Mohabir has asked both the Prosecution and Defence to file submissions in relation to the issue by Thursday. He will then hand down his decision on a subsequent date.  

You must be logged in to post a comment Login