The Leader of the Opposition, Azruddin Mohamed will remain on remand in relation to a cybercrime charge after the High Court dismissed an application filed by his mother to overturn Magistrate Abigail Gibbs’ decision not to grant him.
In her 44-page long decision, Justice Priscilla Chandra-Hanif ruled that Magistrate Gibbs was well within her right as an officer of the Court to consider both the antecedents and patterns of alleged conduct in assessing future risk.
“This Court considers that the Magistrate was entitled, in principle, to evaluate the cumulative significance of the criminal proceedings and the circumstances properly placed before her, including any material relating to alleged witness interference, the nature of the subsequent cybercrime charge, any acknowledgment of relevant conduct and the explanation accompanying it, the potential custodial consequences of the charge, and the Applicant’s demonstrated compliance with bail conditions imposed in other proceedings,” Justice Chandra-Hanif ruled.
She ruled that the law does not ordinarily require a Court to await the Commission of another offence before recognizing a risk that such an offence may occur.
Justice Chandra-Hanif said in the case of the Opposition Leader, the Prosecution’s contention went beyond the bare fact that the applicant had been charged with other offences.
According to the High Court Judge, the Prosecution established a connection between the alleged conduct underlying the different charges, including allegations relating to obstruction of justice, interference with witnesses and the handling of material associated with the wider criminal proceedings.
“The learned Magistrate was therefore required to assess whether the information placed before her provided a sufficiently reliable and rational foundation for the inference that the Applicant’s release on bail presented a real risk of further offending. The question was not whether the Applicant had committed the other offences, which remained matters for determination by the courts properly seized of those proceedings, but whether the circumstances disclosed a relevant and sufficiently substantiated risk for bail purposes,” Justice Chandra-Hanif reasoned.
Justice Chandra-Hanif, in arriving at her decision also took into consideration the issue of witness intimidation, for which Mohamed was also accused.
She said the risk that an accused may interfere with witnesses, influence evidence or otherwise obstruct the proper investigation and prosecution of criminal offences is a serious threat to the administration of criminal justice.
“Witness intimidation strikes at the integrity of the judicial process itself. The administration of criminal justice depends upon the ability of witnesses to give evidence freely and without improper influence. Accordingly, where sufficiently grounded information is presented suggesting a real risk of such interference, a Magistrate may properly attach substantial weight to that concern, even at the preliminary stage of proceedings. This does not require proof beyond reasonable doubt that intimidation has occurred, nor does it permit an unsubstantiated assertion of intimidation to justify detention. The judicial officer must be satisfied that the concern has a rational and sufficient foundation in the circumstances,” the Judge said.
In her ruling, Justice Chandra-Hanif pointed out that it was the Attorneys for the Opposition Leader, who, while addressing Magistrate Gibbs at the Sparendaam Magistrate’s Court, introduced the other pending proceedings.
She said a careful examination of the transcript of the bail hearing would reveal that it was the Applicant’s own attorneys who introduced, and made detailed submissions concerning, the other criminal charges pending before different Courts. These matters, she said, were not introduced solely by the prosecution as unrelated allegations intended to prejudice the applicant.
“In doing so, the Defence itself invited the learned Magistrate to consider the relationship between the various criminal proceedings and the significance of events occurring in those proceedings to the charge then before her,” the Judge said.
Justice Chandra-Hanif said having invited the Magistrate to examine the relationship between the pending charges for the purpose of demonstrating the alleged weakness of the prosecution’s cybercrime case, the Opposition Leader cannot reasonably maintain that the Magistrate was prohibited from considering the same circumstances when evaluating the prosecution’s submissions.
Attorney General Anil Nandlall, who was one of the respondents in the case, praised the ruling.
However, Attorney-at-Law Siand Dhurjon, though not weighing in on the ruling, told News Source that he will be appealing the decision of the Court.
He said Mohamed’s legal team will also make another application to Magistrate Gibbs next Tuesday for bail to be granted when the Cybercrime case comes up again at the Sparendaam Magistrate’s Court.











You must be logged in to post a comment Login