Speaker denies Opposition Leader’s request to join parliamentary sittings virtually while on remand

Speaker denies Opposition Leader’s request to join parliamentary sittings virtually while on remand

Explaining that he has no authority to to set aside the lawful detention of a member on remand, Speaker of the National Assembly, Manzoor Nadir, this morning denied a request from the Leader of the Opposition to join the parliamentary sittings virtually as he remains on remand in prison.

Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed was remanded to prison two weeks ago after he was charged in a cybercrime related matter. He formally made a request last week to join the Parliamentary sittings virtually, leading the speaker to address the issue at the start of this morning’s sitting.

The Speaker said while the he exercises authority over Parliamentary conduct and sittings, that authority does not extend to setting aside, varying or suspending an order of the judiciary.

Mr. Nadir said when a request is made from a Member in custody to participate remotely, the position under parliamentary procedure does not of itself authorise Prison authorities to provide facilities, access, or communication with their legal obligations. He said any such arrangement must have a lawful basis, in respect of the existing order of the Court.

“The Assembly must respect the independence of the judiciary just as the judiciary must respect the Constitutional functions of Parliament. The Speaker of the National Assembly has no authority by virtue of that office alone, to override and order of remand, or to compel the release or the production of a member lawfully detained pursuant to a judicial order. Additionally, this honourable House cannot in exercising its legislative function assume the powers of the judiciary, or set aside the lawful requirements governing detention of any person including one of its own members. In this regard, I have to deny the request of the Honourable member”

The Speaker noted that while Standing Order 106 of the National Assembly makes provisions for members who are unable to attend sittings of the National Assembly, those provisions do not extend to members who may be behind bars on remand, although they remain members by virtue of not being convicted.

The Speaker said his position will remain in place until there is some other order or until another Speaker takes a different position.

Last week, the Attorneys for the Opposition Leader had indicated that they initially sought the Prison Service’s guidance and permission for the Opposition Leader to be provided with the facilities to attend sittings of the National Assembly virtually, but that was denied.

You must be logged in to post a comment Login