Government and Opposition clash over “unlimited” benefits for former Presidents Bill

Government and Opposition clash over “unlimited” benefits for former Presidents Bill

In a heated debate that will continue next Monday, the Government and the Opposition clashed in the National Assembly on Wednesday night over the Former Presidents (Benefits and other Facilities) Bill, which is intended to replace a 2015 legislation passed under the then A Partnership for National Unity + Alliance For Change (APNU+AFC) Government.

Rising in defence of the Bill, Senior Minister of Finance, Dr Ashni Singh told the House that any nation that respects itself would treat its former presidents with the dignity they deserve, having left an indelible mark on the country.

“The civilized practice of nations is to ensure that those who have carried the weight of the highest office of the land are not in their later years reduced to circumstances that would embarrass that office, and would be afforded very basic facilities. This is not difficult to grasp. When we honor a former president, we honour ourselves,” Minister Singh submitted to the House.

 He said the People’s Progressive Party/Civic (PPP/C) throughout its time in Office, has held that principle consistently, ensuring that former presidents are treated with the respect befitting their Office, irrespective of their political party.

The 2026 Bill, he said, is intended to restore the Former Presidents (Benefits and Other Facilities) Act, which was passed by the PPP/C Administration in 2009, but was amended in 2015 under the David Granger Administration. The existing legislation places a cap on the benefits of formers presidents.

Minister Singh told the House that prior to 2009, there was no legislative or structural framework under which former presidents received their benefits. It was explained that those benefits were received at the discretion of the Government in Office.

“It goes without saying that when benefits are provided by discretion they can be granted capriciously and they can be withdrawn capriciously. There is no clarity, there is no transparency because there is no framework written down. There is no accountability because there is no written standard against which to measure. What the 2009 Act did was to take these arrangements out of the realms of discretion and write them down into the Statute Books where they can be seen, debated, and indeed held to account,” Minister Singh said.

He pushed back against the notion that the 2009 Act was intended to grant “unlimited” benefits to former Presidents. The APNU+AFC Administration had described the 2009 Act as “vulgar”, but Minister Singh told the House that between 2009 and 2015, the benefits and facilitates granted to former presidents were grossly misrepresented.

He said the “caps” introduced under the 2015 legislation were only applicable to former President David Granger, adding that 2026 Bill presents an opportunity to correct that “historic wrong.”

A Partnership for National Unity (APNU) Member of Parliament, Sharma Solomon told the House the Opposition does not believe that former presidents should be denied the dignity they deserve, but said everyone who has served the nation deserves to retire with dignity.

“Dignity is the ability to retire without being abandoned the society to which one has given their life. It is being able to pay your bills, purchase your medication, just like the minister said the former presidents would want to do, put food on your table and maintain your household without having to depend on the good will of others. It is the assurance that after 30 or 40 years of honoured service you would live without humiliation of poverty,” MP Solomon said.

He submitted that the principles of dignity cannot change according to the office one occupies, as he made a case for public servants including teachers and nurses, to be also treated with the dignity they deserve.

MP Solomon took aim at Clause 2 of the proposed legislation, which proposes nine categories of lifetime benefits to former presidents in addition to their pension.

“The former President is entitled to water, electricity, telephone service at his residence, while the ordinary Guyanese must struggle with their utility bills and family. People of Linden and Guyana as a whole continue to contend with unreliable electricity,” he said.

MP Solomon said the unlimited resources afforded to former presidents, who already benefit from a presidential pension, cannot be acceptable when regular Guyanese are suffering.

We Invest in Nationhood (WIN) Member of Parliament, Vishnu Panday, in a fiery presentation, told the House that the Opposition’s primary concern is about “the excesses” in the bill.

“The excesses in the bill, that’s where the problem lies, that’s where the contention is. And if in your training, we need to understand that if we have a contentious situation, we have to address it,” MP Panday told the House.

Forward Guyana Movement (FGM) Member of Parliament, Amanza Walton, in a spirited address, submitted that the Bill comes at a time when former presidents are currently enjoying a minimum of $2.2 million or US$11,000 per month in pension benefits.

MP Walton said it is not that the people of Guyana oppose former presidents receiving benefits, explaining that the problem lies with the provision of unlimited benefits.

The debate will continue next Monday.

With the Government having a majority in the House, the Bill is likely to be passed without any hurdle.

You must be logged in to post a comment Login